Type and hit ENTER

Commonly used tags...

2026 Anna Calvi Ash Badly Drawn Boy Big Boutique Brighton Brighton Festival Brighton Fringe Brighton Pride British Sea Power Cinecity Editors Eliza Skelton FatBoy Slim Lewes Psychedelic Festival Lime Garden Locally Sourced Lost & Found Love Supreme Festival Maccabees Melting Vinyl Miles Kane Mutations Festival Nick Cave On The Beach Passenger Poets Vs MCs Politics Rag'n'Bone Man Record Store Day Sairie Save Our Venues Six Of The Best Source Virgins Streets Of Brighton Street Source Tattoos The Great Escape Thursday Tru Thoughts Unsung Heroes
  • Home
  • News
  • Previews
  • Reviews
  • Features
  • Food
  • Tickets
  • Contact
  • Contribute
  • Advertise
  • Home
  • News
  • Previews
  • Reviews
  • Features
  • Food
  • Tickets
  • Contact
    • Contact
    • Contribute
    • Advertise
Reviews

Idles Review

Sep 4, 2018
-
Posted by Ben Miller

With a tightly-guarded ticket list and a snaking queue onto the street outside, a tangible sense of anticipatory tension, uncertainty and thrill surrounds Idles’ early evening takeover of Komedia’s dark downstairs cavern, expanded from an in-store to accommodate demand.

Put on for fans who have bought new album ‘Joy As An Act Of Resistance’, there’s a whisper the band might have enforced an over-demanding schedule on themselves, having been minded to test the speakers and door hinges at a shop in Portsmouth earlier in the day. Their earlier soundcheck here, though, is said to have comprehensively allayed any concerns, with reports of a clobberingly loud, Swans-style tune-up.

A photo of the band in a packed room in a photo by Sam Sesemann as part of an Idles review

Despite Idles being in the house, a lengthy wait ensues. The delay adds to the feel of this being a fully-fledged show rather than a passing promotional opportunity, and gives the room time to steadily morph from sparse post-work buzz to packed and expectant mob. Sure enough, within the space of half a song, these knowingly brutal Bristolians set a ferocious tone for a measured yet destructive display of near-carnal force.

Looking something like a cross between a Victorian malcontent and a revolutionary pirate, chief Idle Joe Talbot takes his responsibilities seriously and makes no secret of his troubled past – these days, he’s an eloquently persuasive poster boy against internalising and compounding personal problems. ‘1049 Gotho’, introduced by Talbot as a description of depression, sees him worry about possessing a body and mind unfit for life’s trials, but also blindsides with its grisly eroticism (“I pissed in the sink / As she slowly undressed”).

A photo of the band in a packed room in a photo by Sam Sesemann as part of an Idles review

As they batter their guitars and drums, all five members strike a picture of cheery, violent relentlessness. They’re furiously impressive, not least on the unbridled anger of Talbot’s tribute to his mother, on which he decries the trappings of poverty and suggests Tories fear rich and educated enemies. Still, for all his cathartic anger and volcanic philosophising, this is more than an extended therapy session, becoming a generous round of request-taking from the pit, interspersed with the odd gutteral barb.

Like Slaves, their fellow punk snarlers to have played at the invitation of Resident recently, Idles combine a consistent vehemence with a certain inscrutability. As the album title suggests, they want to promote liberal openness, dialogue about social and political divisions and, optimistically, love. But doing that, for Talbot, inevitably entails singing about the things he hates – Brexit, inequality, toxic masculinity, elitism.

A photo of the band in a packed room in a photo by Sam Sesemann as part of an Idles review

By the time they roll out ‘Danny Nedelko’, their single written for the Ukrainian leader of the band Heavy Lungs, providing a personal swerve on the voice lacked by immigrants, the atmosphere is approaching genuine anarchy. It has, says Talbot, made them feel like The Beatles. When he thanks security staff for keeping everyone safe, it’s sincere.

Part of this incendiary mood is down to Idles’ more composed sections, when they show a taste for the haunting and cinematic, tensely building into successive explosions of rage and wit. Without the unexpected illness of someone connected to the band, explains Talbot, their set would have gone on longer. Viewers at the front, where a full-on pile-on seems in motion, might be glad to get their breaths back.

Komedia, Monday 3rd September 2018
Photos by Sam Sesemann

Sep 4, 2018
Email
Ben Miller
Ben Miller is a SOURCE feature writer and reporter.
← PREVIOUS POST
Steve Davis and Kavus Torabi, Fri 5th Oct
NEXT POST →
Brownswood comes to Brighton
Mailing List

Recent Posts
  • Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland Review
    Aug 12, 2026

    Alice’s adventures as you’ve never seen them before; clever and funny, brilliant and bonkers: family friendly fun.

  • Play On Presents: Behind The Curtain, Tuesday 25th August
    Aug 11, 2026

    Play On Theatre return with two special performances backstage at the iconic Brighton Theatre Royal

  • Pete & Mila Molinari, Weds 23rd September
    Aug 10, 2026

    Pete Molinari makes a welcome return to Brighton with a rare show at The Prince Albert next month.

  • Rob Luis and Rohan Rokit DJ at Alphabet
    Our Connection: Rob Luis and Rohan Rokit at Alphabet, Review
    Aug 9, 2026

    Smokey, laid back and funky, SOURCE joined in the fun at the latest session from TruThought's label head.

  • ‘One Day In Brighton’ Netpol Report Published
    Aug 8, 2026

    The shocking report detailing the police's actions on 13th June was launched yesterday.

  • Mutations 2026 Full Line Up Announcement
    Aug 5, 2026

    A hole massive heap of the good stuff has joined Mike D 5d and Fatdog on the Mutations line up!

  • Ouse Valley Folk Festival, 28-29th August
    Aug 4, 2026

    Goblin Band and Paul Hartnoll to appear in an exciting folk festival along the coast in Newhaven.

  • Depot Dance DJing in Trafalgar Street at the Carnival Against Fascism
    NetPol ‘One Day in Brighton’ report launch, Friday 7 August
    Aug 3, 2026

    Report into the Carnival Against Fascism policing released this Friday

Website developed in Brighton by Infobo
Copyright © Brighton Source 2009-2023
Idles Review - Brighton Source